
Dunkin Donuts is to Boston as Starbucks is to New York City. That is to say, Dunkin Donuts is practically viral. I must say that I don't prefer one over the other simply because their function is purely caffeine delivery. I'm not going to argue over which has more charm, since chains cannot have charm.
DRIP COFFEEThere is absolutely no doubt that Dunkin Donuts brewed coffee is far better than the bitter bitter brew of Starbucks. Not only does Dunkin's coffee taste better, but it is cheaper. Also, DD is a drip coffee kind of place. The minute you go to DD and start modifying your latte past the point of recognition--the avid Starbucksgoer's favorite pastime--you'll quickly realize you're not in Midtown anymore by the resulting glares. You will be judged for being a pretentious New Yorker.
ESPRESSO DRINKSStarbucks edges out DD when it comes to espresso based drinks. I have ordered infinite cappuccinos there, and about 65% of the time they are tasty. Yes, cappuccinos easily become lattes when you encounter the novice barista, but you can count on the espresso based coffee to be perfectly satisfying. My mom once said many years ago that Starbucks espresso drinks are definitely not the best in the world, but they are good enough AND they are everywhere. You know you will
probably get a serviceable cappuccino both from a Starbucks on the Upper West Side of Manhattan and also from one in Pacific Palisades, California. (Note: We cannot vouch for cappuccinos in Tulsa, Oklahoma.)
On a few occasions, I have attempted to order a cappuccino from DD. Calling it a wet cappuccino is wrong. Calling it a latte is also inaccurate. It is just a cup of hot milk.
FOODThis is where there's no real point in comparing. Starbucks promotes itself as having more gourmet options with items like "Perfect Oatmeal." Dunkin Donuts is home of the munchkin. Each is catering to different demographics. Even if you claim to be above Dunkin Donuts, don't kid yourself. Everyone loves a chocolate glazed munchkin. It is one of the world's great periodic culinary guilty pleasures.
CUPSI commend Dunkin Donuts for it's medium size cup top. It has a built in device that allows you to block the drinking hole, which is key when rushing to catch a train, taxi or flashing pedestrian light. This device also comes into play when one has to tote multiple cups of coffee. We all know I just left publishing. Publishing is known for two things: words and coffee runs. Believe me, if I had been sent to Dunkin Donuts for coffee runs during my publishing career, I would have never dealt with Starbucks foam spray that escapes from the drinking hole of their solo lids. Yellowstone National Park and standing on a coastal rocks at high tide are the metaphors that come to mind. Though, Starbucks makes up for this major annoyance from November 1st to December 31st with their Christmas cups. My love and affection for those cups is beyond words. Let's just say that I when speak about them, I slip into capital letters followed by many exclamation points...
Your Local Coffee ShopLiving in NY certainly racked up my patronage at Starbucks. But, I will always prefer a local coffee shop. One where the servers may not know your name, but they know you. They let you sit for hours and maybe pick up a coffee if you're a dollar short that day, knowing you'll be back to buy another and put a tip in the jar next time. These are the kind of coffee shops that invite you to linger over your coffee. Cafes like this promote writing, reflection, and profound conversation. The Hungarian Coffee Shop in NYC is a great example of a truly awesome coffee shop.
There is a Cafe near my Cambridge apartment that also embodies the perfect coffee shop. It is only open from 7 am to 4 pm and serves the happiest cappuccino I've had in a long time. After utilizing Starbucks in NYC for so long, it is amazing to sit at Cafe Rustica. In NYC, the world stops for no one. In fact, it picks up its pace. Sure, you can get a ceramic mug if you ask for it Starbucks, but the city and world spins at break neck pace outside. You're sure to fall behind if you stop to smell the roses and sip your latte. At Rustica, however, they have a set of free newspapers for you to peruse. They will bring you your coffee if the line is backed up a little. They sprinkle cinnamon or chocolate on top. And though I am neither in NYC nor am I in my Cambridge apartment, I take a sip and feel at home.