Milk is captivating without even breaking a sweat. There's a certain point when the richness of history sends a movie plot into autopilot. I'm not trying to undermine the writer Dustin Lance Black's work on Milk, but at it's most rudimentary form, Harvey Milk's story is a touching and awesome one. What struck me most about the film was the overall ease about it. The story flowed smoothly--the 2 hour length was shockingly humble in this day and age of 3 hour movies. The cast slipped into their characters effortlessly, which is most clear when the male actors share affectionate scenes without clamming up like a robot. This ease is ironic, when you consider the insurmountable barrier that Harvey Milk faced and felled. Like any historical film, there is a great risk of coming off as didactic. Sean Penn derails this with his light touch. Harvey Milk is not portrayed as perfect or Christ-like (as demonstrated through his MAJOR mistake of staying with his second partner in the film, Jack Lira--the epitome of needy). He was simply persistent--stubborn actually. But it takes that to take on the monsters he encountered. I've been raised in an era where sexuality, race, and gender have had isolated moments of discrimination. I take for granted what older generations have arranged--almost seamlessly, as far as a history text book chapter is concerned--for my generation. We know nothing about the Anita Bryants and the Senator Briggs of olden days. I am not so naive to think that people don't feel or think that way anymore, but at least they have been reduced (for the most part, though I can't speak for those red states...) to muttering at their TVs or newspapers in the privacy of their own homes.
Forgive me, for I am about to get a little cheesy. I found the film even more moving after seeing an African American get elected this year. I did not experience the weight of historical figures like Milk or Dr. Martin Luther King when they were pushing for change, but I naively assumed I understood their fights. Milk gently showed me how ignorant I am of what it took to get the US to where it is today. This year, I had the privilege of voting for a man with a solid campaign. In 2008, his campaign could outshine the fact that he was African American. No matter how many of Hollywood's renditions of civil rights activism I see on the silver screen, I will remain naive of the real-time gravity.
That is not to say that being homosexual today is a picnic, by any means. I do not wish to make that claim. Though, it certainly is a bit easier than in Milk's day. All I know is that I was beyond moved during the final 10 minutes of the movie. I sat fighting back tears at the sight of the candlelight vigil. I cannot imagine how people find the courage to fight adversity, particularly when the world in which I was raised did not offer any concrete example of what adversity actually is.
.jpg)

